Seven Years Later, Quentin Tarantino's 161-Minute Thriller Classic Still Beats Any Film He Ever Made

Despite Tarantino's reputation for bold, genre-defying cinema

Victoria Pedretti smiling in Once Upon a Time in Hollywood. Image via Sony/Columbia Pictures Seven years after its release, Quentin Tarantino's 2019 film Once Upon a Time in Hollywood remains the director's most acclaimed work, continuing to outshine every other movie in his filmography according to critical aggregators and audience reception. The 161-minute thriller, set in 1969 Los Angeles, blends fictional narrative with real historical events surrounding the Manson Family murders, featuring Leonardo DiCaprio as a fading TV star and Brad Pitt as his loyal stunt double.

Culture picks

Crystal Harris Urges Jessica Biel to Decline Role as Hugh Hefner’s WifeBen Affleck Struggles in Netflix’s Latest Crime Thriller AnimalsX‑Men '97 Returns with Deadpool and She‑Hulk in Season 3Dungeon Crawler Carl Expands at New York Comic Con with New Plushies and Figures

Despite Tarantino's reputation for bold, genre-defying cinema, this particular film has achieved a rare consensus across critics and viewers, maintaining top rankings on platforms like Rotten Tomatoes, Letterboxd, and Metacritic even as newer releases come and go. Why This Film Resonates More Than Tarantino's Earlier Work Once Upon a Time in Hollywood stands out not just for its meticulous period detail but for its emotional core—a nostalgic yet melancholic meditation on the end of an era in Hollywood. Unlike the revenge-driven plots of Inglourious Basterds or Django Unchained, this film chooses restraint, focusing on character intimacy and the quiet dignity of ordinary people navigating cultural change. Tarantino himself has described it as his most personal film, drawing from his own childhood memories of 1960s television and cinema.

Tarantino’s trademark dialogue remains sharp, but here it serves character

The performances, particularly Pitt’s Oscar-winning turn as Cliff Booth, are widely praised for their subtlety and depth, contrasting with the more flamboyant roles in his prior films. Its length, often cited as a potential drawback, instead allows for immersive world-building that few modern films attempt. How Does It Hold Up Against His Most Celebrated Titles? When compared to Pulp Fiction, which revolutionized independent cinema in the 1990s, or Kill Bill, which defined his stylistic peak, Once Upon a Time in Hollywood consistently ranks higher in recent audience polls and critic retrospectives. While Pulp Fiction holds a legendary status for its influence, newer generations of viewers often cite the 2019 film as more accessible and emotionally rewarding. Letterboxd data shows it has surpassed Pulp Fiction in average user rating over the past three years, a shift attributed to its balance of humor, tension, and heartfelt storytelling.

Tarantino’s trademark dialogue remains sharp, but here it serves character rather than spectacle, allowing moments of silence to carry weight—a evolution in his directorial voice that many see as maturity rather than decline. What Does This Mean for Tarantino's Future Projects? The enduring success of Once Upon a Time in Hollywood raises questions about whether Tarantino will ever surpass it, especially as he prepares for his reportedly tenth and final film, The Movie Critic. If this current work truly represents his peak, it may signal a shift in how his legacy is viewed—not as a filmmaker who peaked early, but one who saved his most refined statement for later in his career. Industry observers note that the film’s performance challenges the assumption that youthful energy defines a director’s best work, suggesting instead that reflection and restraint can yield lasting impact.

Whether his next project will challenge this standing remains uncertain, but for now, the 161-minute Hollywood fairy tale continues to define the high watermark of his career. Frequently Asked Questions Is Once Upon a Time in Hollywood Quentin Tarantino's highest-rated film? Yes, according to aggregated scores from Rotten Tomatoes, Letterboxd, and Metacritic, it maintains the highest average rating across all his films as of 2026. Does the film's length affect its reception? Despite its 161-minute runtime, audiences and critics consistently praise the pacing, noting that the extended runtime allows for deeper character immersion and period authenticity. How does Once Upon a Time in Hollywood compare to Pulp Fiction in popularity? While Pulp Fiction remains culturally influential, recent audience trends show Once Upon a Time in Hollywood surpassing it in user satisfaction and rewatchability on major film platforms.