Ben McDonnell Reveals New Blood Secrets and Talks About His Bond With Alan
[This article contains spoilers through the 10th episode of The Traitors: New Blood.]
Culture picks
Project Hail Mary spin-off gets major VR upgrade fans demanded
Cult Horror Favorite Ice Cream Man Returns for Long-Awaited Sequel
Kanye West Faces Another Copyright Lawsuit Over Unlicensed Samples
Why Wearable Tech Is Quietly Saving Senior LivesBen McDonnell had just finished watching all episodes when he got the call to join the fifth season of the Peacock and NBC Emmy-winning reality competition. The barrel racer living on a Texas ranch with his husband, who also hosts the weekly comedy podcast „It's Ben a Week,”accepted the challenge. He soon found himself in a Scottish castle, living with strangers under host Alan Cumming's watch.
How did Hollywood lure you back for this show, given you are a trained actor
McDonnell became the king of one-liners and the fans' favorite gay cowboy until he was eliminated in the penultimate episode. „Every morning I woke up in a panic, fearing elimination. But on the day I was 'killed,' I was remarkably calm,”McDonnell told The Hollywood Reporter.
Although he entered the game assuming his personality would make him a Traitor, the truth that he was a Loyal took him further than the $250,000 prize. „I didn't think the cast would love me for who I am,”he said. „That part was unexpectedly healing when you didn't even know you were broken.”Below, opening up to THR, McDonnell reveals a surprise for fans and castmates (he is actually a trained actor), discusses the hardest parts of filming, such as giving up his phone, and explains why Cumming is a national treasure who inspired the name of his new podcast, Alan Cunningham.
Were you a fan of The Traitors?
This experience was truly one of the most emotional acting experiences of my life. On a film set, you present a character, but when the director says „cut,”you return to yourself. In The Traitors, the director never says „cut.”You are in character all the time. Even when cameras are off, you must maintain intensity. I have a large, loud personality, so I had to tone it down. I didn't tell anyone I am an actor. I emphasized being „this gay cowboy,”which is not a lie. The producers hired me to play a game about deception. The show is not a union production, so there are definitely people there not pursuing acting careers. For example, Abby L. didn't even have Instagram before joining. She is an astrophysicist. There are people from all walks of life, which was amazing.
Were you pursuing acting at that time? Or did it feel like lucky timing?
I went to BravoCon and saw a promo for The Traitors. I asked my friend, „What is The Traitors?”She said, „You don't watch The Traitors? You have to see it. It's the best show.”I said, „Okay, maybe.”Then, in Texas, we had a terrible ice storm in January. My husband AJ went out and asked, „What are you watching?”I said, „Let's watch this thing called The Traitors.”I started an episode and was immediately captivated. I watched every season of the UK show and every season of the US show. Two weeks later, I got the call: „Would you be interested in The Traitors?”I replied, „I just binged it all. I'm crazy.”The next thing I knew, I was in a Scottish castle with Alan Cumming, playing a real-life Clue in the Scottish Highlands.
Acting was always my primary goal. As an actor, I never thought I would do reality TV. For a long time, I was against it. I had other offers for a reality show idea and always said, „You can't do reality and be taken seriously as an actor.”I feel a shift has happened. Ten years ago, I said, „I can't be gay and an actor because I'll be boxed in.”That's not really the case now. You can be gay and play straight roles. It's not as scary as before. The same applies to reality. Look at Ariana Madix from Vanderpump Rules. She is on Broadway. She is in an NBC show. She does all kinds of things. So many reality stars are now pursuing roles in series and films.
You said you hoped to be a Traitor. What was your strategy when you entered
I believe it's not as scary, but scripted television and films were always my number one priority.
I only thought about being a Traitor. It was so fixed in my mind. There was absolutely no question of not being a Traitor. Crazy, that didn't even occur to me.