‘Stuffed’ Review: Jodie Comer Rises Above a Limp, Gross-Out Corpse-Themed Musical

Melling matches her intensity, though his character remains less defined

At the Toronto International Film Festival, Jodie Comer and Harry Melling star in „Stuffed,” a body-horror musical that attempts to blend romance with grotesque imagery. The film follows two lonely individuals drawn together through a shared fascination with taxidermy and death, set against a backdrop of surreal musical numbers. Despite its ambitious premise, the execution falters under uneven tone and overreliance on shock value. Comer delivers a compelling performance, grounding the film’s absurdity with emotional authenticity that elevates the material beyond its gimmicky surface. Her portrayal of a withdrawn taxidermist finding unexpected connection showcases her range, even as the script struggles to balance horror, humor, and heart.

Culture picks

Diedre Hall Brings Soap Opera Depth to Star Trek: Strange New WorldsRobert Plant and Saving Grace Prepare Digital Release of All That Glitters… EPPhoebe Bridgers Releases New Track for A24 Film PrimetimeHBO Secures Rights for Cole Escola’s „Oh, Mary!” Live Performance

Melling matches her intensity, though his character remains less defined, serving more as a mirror to her journey than a fully realized counterpart. Why the Musical Elements Undermine the Horror The film’s original songs, intended to heighten emotional beats, often disrupt tension with jarring shifts in tone. Lyrics lean heavily on macabre wordplay, but the melodies lack memorability, leaving numbers feeling more like interruptions than extensions of the narrative. Choreography incorporates taxidermy tools and preserved specimens as props, creating visually striking moments that nonetheless feel disconnected from the story’s emotional core. Critics noted that the musical aspects seem grafted on rather than grown from the characters’ inner lives. Can Gore and Romance Coexist in Musical Form? „Stuffed” raises the question of whether body horror and romantic musicals can meaningfully intersect without one undermining the other.

While the film earns credit for attempting a bold hybrid genre

While the film earns credit for attempting a bold hybrid genre, its failure to integrate the musical components with the horror elements results in a work that feels torn between intentions. The strongest scenes occur during quiet, dialogue-driven moments where Comer and Melling’s chemistry suggests a deeper, more conventional romance struggling to emerge from beneath the spectacle. The film’s ultimate limitation lies in its commitment to shock over substance; the grotesque imagery, while initially arresting, loses impact through repetition without narrative justification. As a TIFF premiere, „Stuffed” signals ambition but highlights the risks of genre experimentation when tonal control slips. It may find appreciation among fans of avant-garde musicals or extreme horror, yet its broader appeal remains limited by its inability to satisfy either genre’s expectations fully. Frequently Asked Questions Is „Stuffed” primarily a horror film or a musical?

It attempts to be both, blending body horror with original musical numbers, though critics argue the genres are not fully integrated. What makes Jodie Comer’s performance stand out? She brings emotional depth and realism to a role that could have been one-note, anchoring the film’s absurdity with genuine vulnerability. Does the film offer a meaningful commentary on loneliness? While loneliness is a central theme, the exploration is superficial, overshadowed by the film’s focus on grotesque imagery and musical set pieces.